0911111111

The effect of feeding diets of different molasses levels on rumen fermentation digestibility, nitrogen balance and body weight gain in yearling sheep.

Comments Disabled

Muna, M.M. Ahmed, Sara, R. Beheri 1 and A.A. Lutfi2

Institute of Environmental Studies. P. 0. Box 321. Khartoum-Sudan.

SUMMARY

The effect of different molasses levels (30, 35, 40, and 45%) in the diet of sheep was investigated. Four rations were formulated so as to be iso-caloric and iso-nitrogenous, and in which the different molasses levels replaced groundnut hulls in a basal ration of wheat bran and groundnut cake. 32 yearling sheep were subjected to two trials, feeding and digestibility, where in the former a completely randomized design was used with eight animals in each treatment and in the latter a 4X4 Latin Square design was used. The results revealed that dry matter intake decreased steadily with the increase of molasses level, but no significant differences could be detected. Body weight gain increased (P<0.05) with the 30 and 40% molasses levels although the amounts of nitrogen retained decreased (P<0.05) with the 40% level suggesting that the gain in weight could be due to fat deposition. Higher (P<0.05) amounts of nitrogen retention were observed with the 30 and 35% levels. Ether extract digestibility at the 35% level proved to be significant (P<0.05). Rumen pattern of fermentation or blood urea nitrogen did not differ much with the different diets. However, the sampling time showed that, rumen pH and rumen ammonia nitrogen decreased while rumen volatile fatty acids increased 6 hours post-feeding but without significant differences.

INTRODUCTION

Molasses is an inexpensive and valuable energy source, readily available worldwide that has been used for ruminants feeding (Niino et al., 1992). It could be utilized for several purposes, in dry feed, in silage making as urea carrier, in liquid supplements and in molasses blocks (Goll, 1981). Due to its laxative effect, digestive disturbances might arise and so a 20% level is recommended as maximum level (Scary, 1988). Other authors went up to 30% without adverse effect (Sibanada et al., 1987).

Digestibility of dry matter of sheep showed an improvement upon addition of 10% molasses to desert grasses (Mirgani and Bakit, 1990) or to a commercial mixture (Leontwicz et al., 1982). Similar results were obtained when molasses was used to replace different diets such as rice bran (Lenal et al., 1989), rice straw (Nakanishi 1992) or corn (Hatch and Beeson, 1972). Furthermore, crude protein digestibility was also found to be increased by the inclusion of molasses at 10 or 20% levels (Karalazos and Swan, 1972) or added to a basal diet of meadow grass hay (Weidmeier et al., 1992) or sodium hydroxide treated straw (El Yassin and Fonterot, 1991). Above 30% level, molasses addition was found to have no effect on fiber digestibility (Lemal et al., 1989).

Best weight gain was obtained with 30% inclusion of molasses in the diet of sheep (Pollot and Ahmed, 1979). Daily weight gain of 900g for cattle fattened on 40% molasses feeds was also observed (Cleasby, 1953).

In zebu bull a.970g/day was recorded (Preston et al., 1969). Inclusion of molasses in the diet of sheep was found to increase both intake (Ahmed and Ahmed, 1983) and forage utilization (Kalili et al., 1993). The present study was initiated with the objective to investigate the effect of inclusion of molasses at different levels (30-45%) in sheep fattening diets on rumen fermentation pattern, digestibility, nitrogen balance, and weight gain.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Experimental Animals:

Thirty-two uncastrated healthy yearling desert rams were used in this experiment. They aged between 1-1.5 years and weighed between 27-29 ± 1.2 kg at the beginning of the experiment.

Feeds:

Four rations containing increasing molasses levels (30, 35, 40, and 45%) were formulated to meet the nutrient requirements of sheep (Table 1) and were designated as rations 1, 2, 3, and 4 respectively. The chemical composition of the experimental rations is shown in Table 2. Feed samples were analyzed at regular intervals according to the methods of Association of Official Analytical Chemists (AOAC,

1980). Table 1.  Percentage of ingredientof experimental rations, on dry
matter basis.
Ration / Ingredient1234                        .
Molasses30354045
Wheat bran28.328.328.328.3
Groundnut hulls35302520
Groundnut cake (GNSC)4444
Urea1.71.71.71.7
Salt1.01.01.01.0
Crude protein15.2515.18.15.1315.08
Metabolizable energy    
(MJ/kg DM)9.759.9610.161.0.37

Table 2. Chemical composition of the experimental rations.

Ration / %123                      4 
Dry matter85.984.282.889.4
Organic matter76.7371.7074.3875.18
Ether extract2.180.281.261.0
Crude fiber20.6820.2214.6114.22
Crude protein15.2613.9312.6814.22
Nitrogen free extract52.6652.5363.0556.68
Ash9.2212.58.48.58

Feeding Trials:

The 32 rams were allocated to a completely randomized design where each group of eight animals received one of the formulated rations shown in Table 1. To avoid responses that might have arisen from variations in body weights, animals’ allocations to the different treatments were so that the average body weights in the different groups were nearly the same. The animals were individually tethered in partially shaded enclosures (6 x 6 m2) fenced with thatch fitted together with wire at a height of 2 m. An adaptation period of 14 days was allowed followed by a measurement period of 12 weeks during which food intake and water intake of each animal was taken and body weights recorded on weekly basis. Food was withdrawn overnight before weighing was done in the next morning. The duration of this, study lasted for 98 days.

Digestibility Trial:

At the end of the feeding trial, four animals were randomly selected from each group, fitted with fecal bags, and placed in metabolic cages especially designed for urine collection. In the digestibility trial, the animals were employed to a 4X4 Latin Square design, (4 animals versus 4 treatments). The animals were rotated between the treatments so that there were 16 animals per treatment. During each rotation the animals were allowed an adaptation period of 7 days followed by 7 days measurement period so that this trial lasted for 56 days. During each measurement period, urine samples were collected and analyzed for nitrogen content according to El Shazly (1958), feces analyzed for proximate analysis using the standard methods of AOAC (1980). Rumen liquor samples were collected by a stomach tube, strained through a mesh cloth, and analyzed immediately for pH, ammonia nitrogen (NH3-N) and total volatile fatty acids (VFAs). The pH was measured by a pH meter (Electronic measurement L. T. D. model 4160), NH3-N determination followed the method of Conway (1957) while VFAs was determined by steam distillation as described by Kroman et al. (1967). Blood samples were collected for urea determination level. This was done by jugular vein puncture in non­heprinized tubes, the serum separated was stored at —20°C until assayed for urea serum concentration by the method of Evans (1968).

All of the above samples were taken twice, once before feeding and once 3 hours post-feeding. Animals were fasted overnight for the before feeding samples.

Statistical Analysis:

Analysis of variance was done according to the general linear model procedure of SAS (1990). Duncan multiple range test was used to examine differences between means at a < 0.05.

RESULTS

Chemical composition:

The chemical composition of the rations showed that differences due to the inclusion of molasses was not significant. However, ration 1 had the highest ether extract and crude fiber concentrations, while ration 3 had the highest nitrogen free extract concentration.

Dry matter intake (DMI) and body weight gain:

Total weight gain (Kg) over the experimental period (12 weeks) or average daily weight gain (g) was found to be significantly (P<0.05) low with ration 4 (45% molasses diet) (Table 3). DMI, when expressed as g/d or g/kg°75/day was found to decrease with the increase of molasses level in the rations. However, significant differences could not be detected .

Table 3. Body weight gain, dry matter intake (DMI) and water intake of desert sheep fed different molasses levels over 12 weeks.

Ration / Parameter30354045
Initial weight (kg)28.3+1.328.0+1.027.2+2.426.4+1.0
Final weight (kg)30.1+1.634.3+2.535.2+1.828.1+2.3
Total gain (kg) over    
89 days7.1±3.5a6.3±1.3ab10.1+2.2a3.0±2.4e
Average daily gain(g) 83.0±0.9a73.0±0.04a99±0.06a36.0+0.1b
Dry matter intake (DMI,   
kg)1.07+0.011.03+0.031.02+0.030.71+0.02
g / kg 075/ day87.2+3.184.63+5.384.62+4.460.94+6.2

Values are means of eight animals ± SD

abc

Values within the same row bearing different superscript differ significantly at (P<0.05).

Ruminal components and blood urea nitrogen (BUN):

Sampling time was found to affect ruminal components (Table 4). Both the pH and ammonia nitrogen (NH3-N) decreased 6 hours post-feeding, while total volatile fatty acids (VFAs) increased. BUN seemed to be inconsistent with sampling time. Statistical analysis were carried out for the treatment means between the different rations and no significant differences were detected .

Table 4. Ruminal pH, total volatile fatty acids (VFAs, meq/100
ml), Ruminal ammonia nitrogen (NH3-N, mg/100 ml) and blood

urea nitrogen (BUN, m1/100 ml) molasses levels over 12 weeks.of desertsheep    feddifferent
Rations / Parameters‘             30354045
pH before feeding7.25±0.39 7.17±0.317.20±0.317.18±0.48
pH 6 hrs post-feeding6.70±0.346.66±0.196.76±0.066.73±0.26
VFAs before feeding 0.95±0.270.92±0.49b 1.01±0.40b1.06±0.32b
VFAs 6 hrs post-feeding1.6±0.472.28±0.692.07±0.741.77±0.23
NH3-N before feeding27.83±4.426.95±10.429.93±3.5,26.78±5.4
NH3-N 6 hrs
post-feeding
9.63±6.812.95±5.89.65±10.710.33±3.0
BUN before feeding34.09±8.424.11±3.222.86±7.931.18±8.2
BUN 6 hrs    
post-feeding33.75±4.726.61±6.734.94±10.634.09±8.3
Digestibility:    

Apparent digestibility of the nutrients is shown in Table 5. Ether extract digestion was shown to be the highest (P<0.05) with ration 1(30%) compared to the other rations. Crude fiber digestion was the lower (P<0.05) with rations 3 and 4 compaed to rations 1 and 2. Nitrogen free extract was the lowest (P<0.05) with ration 2 (35%).

Table 5. Apparent digestibility coefficients and total digestible nutrients (TDN, %) and digestible crude protein of different levels of molasses fed to desert sheep.

  Molasses level (%) 
 30354045
Apparent digestibility   
Dry matter61.44±9.756.52±3.161.68±6.563.88±4.1
Organic matter78.10±7.776. 99± 6.380 . 62±3.3    84.5±4.2
Crude protein75.99±12.165.13±9.966.02±6.171.19±1.4
*DCP11.5±1.39.07±0.098.35+0.210.12±1.4
Ether extract87.76±7.6a31.0±7.7b26.25±3.3b42.63±9.8b
Crude fiber44,36±17.9a47.92±11.9a26.67±12.6b30.98±12.6b
Nitrogen free    
Extract67.10±9.7a63.34±5.3b74.68±5.1a71.10±6.4a
TDN59.61±9.352.63±3.260.05±4.953.78±5.1

* DCP = digestible crude protein.

Values are means of eight animals ± SD.

ab Values within the same row bearing different superscript differ significantly at (P<0.05).

Nitrogen balance:

Significant differences in nitrogen intake, or excretion in feces and urinary due to inclusion of molasses at different levels could be detected (Table 6). However, there was a tendency of animals to decrease intake but increase fecal excretion at 40% level. The amount of nitrogen retained when expressed as percent of intake or digested revealed that both the 30 and 35% molasses levels in the rations increased significantly (P<0.05) compared to the 40 and 45% levels.

Table     6.                 Nitrogen balance of desert sheepfed different molasses
level.
Nitrogen balance                                             Molasses level (%) 30                                                      35               4045
Nitrogen intake (g / day)                           24.81±0.97   22.71±0.5317.71±0.4820.63±2.3
Fecal N.(g/day)         5.57±1.5      5.71±1.26.05±0.885.89±1.1
Urinary N. (g/day)  8.46±0.85   8.81+1.98.56±3. 210.24+2.5
N. retained (g/day) 10.39±4.9a    8.19±2.3a3.11±1.5b4.50±2.5b
Nitrogen retained as  
% of intake            40.77±9.8a   36.19±7.9a17.45±9.6b20.67±6.8b
Nitrogen retained as  
% of digested         53.17±18.4a 48.08±9.4a 27.15±17.1b28.89±8.9b

Values are means of eight animals ± SD.

ab Values within the same row bearing different superscript differ significantly at (P<0.05).

DISCUSSION

The steady decrease in dry matter intake with increasing molasses levels in the diet was supported by observations of other workers (Wayman, 1954; Lofgreen and Dtagaki, 1960; Pollot- and Ahmed, 1979; Sanchez and Preston, 1980). Total or daily weight gains were positive up to 40% molasses level in the diet then declined with further increase of molasses in the diet (45%). Positive effects were also in experiments’ with sheep at 10 and 20% levels (Merino et al., 1965). When series of molasses levels were used (15% up to 60%) in the diet of sheep, the 30% level was shown to give the best weight (Pollot and Ahmed, 1979).

Rumen fermentation pattern did not differ significantly between the different rations. The decrease in rumen ammonia nitrogen (NH3-N)

level 6 hours post-feeding could be related to the increase in total volatile fatty acids (VFAs) which is usually used as a source of energy supply that assisted in the incorporation of NI-13-N into microbial cells for microbial protein formation with subsequent decrease in NH3-N level observed after feeding. Furthermore, the high degradability of molasses was well matched with the degradability of other components of the diet, which encouraged microbial multiplication.

Apparent digestibility for the different nutrients could be correlated with the ingredients of each ration. In this context, ether extract level was the highest in ration 1 resulting in high digestion of the lipids. Similar findings were obtained by Balasubramanya et al. (1980). Nitrogen free extract digestions were shown to reflect carbohydrate concentrations in the different rations (Table 4). However, the insignificant differences obtained in this study were similar to those observed in sheep given increasing molasses level (0 – 151.1 g/kg toluene DM) (Givens et al. 1992). Also, the insignificant differences obtained in both dry matter and organic matter digestions were supported by findings of other workers using different molasses levels in the diets of sheep (Umoh, 1983; Carrasco et al. 1993). Crude fiber digestion was suppressed at the 40 or 45% molasses level in the ration, which could be related to the presence of high concentration of soluble sugars accompanied by low fiber content which were known to reduce the activity of cellulolytic bacteria responsible for fiber digestion.

In the present study, sheep rations containing 30 and 35% molasses level showed improved nitrogen retention, which was reflected in increased body weights. However, the highest gain was observed with the 40% level, which could be related to fat deposition as the amount of nitrogen retained at this molasses level was significantly reduced.

It could be concluded that inclusion of molasses at the 30% level was the best economical way for sheep fattening. Although the highest gain was obtained with, the 40% level but that would not be preferred by human consumption due to the high fat content.

REFERENCES

Ahmed, F.A. and Ahmed, A.I. (1993). Intake and digestibility of berseem (Medicago sativa) and sorghum, Abu 70 (Sorghum vulgare) forages by Sudan zebu cattle and desert sheep. Tropical Animal and Health Production. 15: 7-15.

A.O.A.C. (1975). Methods of Analysis. 12th ed. Association of Official Analytical Chemists. Washington D.C., 957pp.

Balausbrammanya, H.K., KrishnmoOrth, U., Mallikaajunappa, S. and Rai, A.V. (1980). Nutrients intake and digestibility in Surthi heifers feeding maize straw impregnated with urea molasses. Indian Veterinary Journal. 57: 561-565:

Carrasco, E., Stuart, R., Fundora, 0. and Febles, I. (1993). Consumption and digestibility in sheep fed different proportions a final molasses/maize in baggasse pith rations. Cuban Journal of Agricultural Science. 27: 275-279.

Cleasby, T.G. (1953). The feeding value of molasses. Proceedings of the South African Sugar Technical Association. 113-120 .

Conway, E.J. (1957). Microdiffusion Analysis and Volumetric Error. 4th edition. London, Crosby —Lockwood and Son Ltd. 173pp.

El Shazly, K. (1958). Studies on the nutritive value of some common Egyptian feeding stuffs. I. Nitrogen retention and ruminal ammonia curves. J. of Agric Sci., Camb. 51: 149-156.

El yassin, F.A. and Fontenot, J.P. (1991). Fermentation characteristics and nutritional value of ruminal content and blood ensiled with untreated or treated NaOH treated wheat straw. Journal of Animal Science. 69: 1751-1758.

Evans, R.T. (1968). Modification  of      its reaction         with

diacetyle monoxime and thiosemi-carbazide. J. of Clinl Path. 21: 527-532.

Givens, D.iI., Moss, A.R. and Everington, J.M. (1992). Nutritional values of care molasses in diets of grass silage and concentrate fed to sheep. Animal Feed Science and Technology. 38 (4): 281-291.

G011, B.O. (1981). Tropical Feed, feed information summaries and nutritive values. FAO. Animal Production and Health series No. 12 (Ed, xviii) Rome, IALY. 529pp.

Hatch, C.F. and Beeson, W.M. (1972). Effect of different levels of cane molasses on nitrogen and energy utilization in urea rations for steers. Journal of Animal Science. 35: 854-858.

Kalili, H., Varikko, T. and Osuji, D.O. (1993). Supplementation of grass hay with molasses in cross breed (Bos Taurus x Bos indicus) non-lactating. Animal Feed Science and Technology. 41: 39-50.

Karaloz, A. and Swan, H. (1977). The nutritional value for sheep of molasses and condensed molasses solubles. Animal Feed Science and Technology. 2: 142-143.

Kroman, P.R., Meyer, J.H., Stielau, W.J. (1967).     Steam

distillation of volatile fa.tty acids in rumen ingesta. J. of Dairy Sci. 50: 37-51.

Lemat, A., Faye, J.C. Buldgen, A. and Compere, R. (1989). Effect of the proportion of liquid molasses on the nutritive value of diets for ruminants based on byproducts available in the Senegal River Valley. Bulletin-des-Recherches Agronomoiques-de-Gamboux. 23 (3): 315-328.

Leontwicz, H., Kulaselek, G., Barei, W. and Chomyszn, M. (1982). Protein and carbohydrate digestion in sheep on diets with condensed molasses solubles. Mezhdunaroknyl Symposium pofiziologii-pisschcherareniya zhrachnykiikh producek firmness, stara zargoza. Sofia Bulgaria. 117 (English abstact).

Lofgreen, G.P. and Otagaki, K.K. (1960). The net energy of black strap molasses for fattening steers as determined by a comparative slaughter technique. Journal of Animal Science. 19: 392-397. Merino, H., Raun, N.S. and Concelenz, E. (1965). The effect of molasses level on growth and ruminal fermentation. Journal of Animal Science, 214 (abstract).

Mirgani, T. and Bakit, S.M. (1990). The effect of intra-ruminal administration of molasses on blood glucose concentration in camels, sheep and goats. World Review of Animal Production. 25 (3): 81-84.

Nakanishi, M., Perera, N., Okamoto, M. and Yoshida, N. (1992). Effect o f molasses on utilization of urea treated straw. Research Bulletin of Obihiro University. 44: 11-17.

NiinoDuponte, R.Y., Carpenter, J.R., Campell, C.M., Kaheiki, M. and Rice, C. (1992). The effect of altering molasses fiber level on nutrient digestibility and energy efficiency of feedlot of rations. Proceedings of American Society Science: 43: 243-246. Pollot, G.E. and Ahmed, F.A. (1979). The effect of feeding diets containing 15, 30, 45, and 60% molasses on performance of Watish lambs (Sudan desert type). Umbanein Livestock Research Bulletin No. 8.

Preston, T.R., Willis, M.B. and Martin, J.I. (1969). Efficiency of utilization for fattening of metabolizable energy of molasses based diets. Journal of Animal Science. 28: 796-801.

Sanzchez, M. and Preston, T.R. (1980). Sugar-cane/juice as cattle feed: Comparisons with molasses in the absence or presence of protein supplement. Tropical Animal Production. 5: 117-123.

SAS Institute Inc. (1990). SAS / STAT User Guide Release 6.3 ed SAS Institute Inc. / Cary Nc.

Scarr, M.J. (1988). The optimal use of agro-industrial by-products and crop residues in Nigeria. Proceedings of the workshop on utilization of agricultural by-products as livestock feeds in Africa. Research Network for Agricultural by-products (ARNAB). 62pp.

Umoh, J.E. (1983). Effect of graded levels of sugar cane molasses on the performance of growing cattle. Tropical Agricultural Trinidad . 60 (4): 297-300.

Wayman, 0., Henk, L.A. andIwanaga, I. (1954). Further studies on the use of cane molasses rations for the dry-lot finishing beef cattle. Hawaii Agricultural Experimental Station Progress Note. 103: 9pp. Weidmeier, R.D., Tanner, B.H., Bair, J.R., Shenton, H.H., Arambel, J.M. and Walters, J.E. (1992). Effects of a new molasses by-product concentrated separator by-product on nutrient digestibility and ruminal fermentation in cattle. Journal of Animal Science. 70: 1936-1940.

Authors:

Muna Mahgoub Mohamed Ahmed Sara Rasheed Sid Ahmed Beheri Asim Abd El Razig Lutfi

تأثير المستويات المختلفة من المولاس علي نمط التخمير في الكرش ، معامل الهضم ، میزان النيتروجين والكسب في الوزن للأغنام ( الضأن ) الصغيرة

مني محجوب محمد أحمد ، سارة رشيد سيد أحمد بحيري وعاصم عبد الرازق لطفي – معهد الدراسات البيئية . ص.ب. 321 الخرطوم

ملخص البحث :

روس بنسب مختلفة ( 300 ، 35 اعلان 4 عنف خصمت محتوياتها بحيث أجريت هذه تاثیر ندا 40 و 45 % ) في عليقة الضاي علي تكون متساوية في مستوي النتروجين والطاقة وذلك بإحلال المولاس القشرة الفول السوداني في العليقة الأساسية التي احتوت على ردة الفسح و آسمان الفول السوداني ، أستخدم عند 32 كيش في تجربتي نسمين وهضم حيث وزعت كل أربعة فرق من الكباش بطريقه عشوائية حرة لشفتي كل منها على نوع واحد من إحدى العلائق المعدة ، كان ذلك بالنسبة التجارب التسمي ، أما بالنسية التجاري الهضم لن أخضعت الحيوانات المنصب اللاتيني ربع ( 4 * 4 ) حيث أخذت كل الفرق حظها في كل العلائق بطريقة عشوائية أبين النتائج أن المادة الجافة المتداولة تناقصت بطريقة تدريجية كلما زادت نسبة المولاس في مع عدم وجود فروقات معنوية . أما الوزن فزاد بصورة معنوية ( 05 = P ) بالنسبة للحيوانات التي تعذت علي 30 و 40 مو لاس بالرغم من وجود نقص معنوي ( 0.05 = P ) في كمية البروتين المحتجز بالنسبة للمجموعة التي تغنت على ( 40 مودم مما دل على أن الزيادة في الوان كان مصدرها الزيادة في الشحم المترسب . ازدادت كمية النتروجين المحتجز بصورة معنوية ( 0.05 > P ) بالنسبة للحيوانات التي تفنت حي 30 و 35 عو لاس زد هضم الدهن في العليقة التي بها نسبة سولاس ( 30 % ( 05 ( 0 = P ) بينما زاد فضم الألياف الخام ( 05 0 = P ) في العليقة التي احتوت علي 30 و % 35 سولاس ، لحمة في تخمر الكرش وكذلك تركيز البوريا في الدم لم يتغير ان تتغير نسبة المولاس في العليقة ولكن حدث تغير نتيجة لتناول الماء حيث قلت حمضية الكرش وكنت نسبة النتروجين المرتبطة بالأمونيا في الجانب الأخر فقد زانت نسبة الأحماض الدهنية الطيارة لمحتوي الكرش عقب 6 ساعات من تناول الطعام ولكن بدون فروقات معنوية

.

Download As : PDF


Subscribe to our Newsletter

[email-subscribers-form id="1"]
All Rights Reserved, Animal Production Research Center © 2020 | Prepared by: Dr. Muhammad Ahmad Al-Khalifa | Design: Mohamed Ahmed